Managing Construction Insurance Costs in Today's Environment

Page 1 of 3
Written by:
Steven D. Davis, McGriff Seibels & Williams
max
mid
min

It is apparent that lean and fit organi­zations represent a platform for long-term survival. With the challenges of the current economic times, contractors are leaving no stones unturned.

They have recognized the importance of imagination, vision and competitive information to survive and succeed in an uncertain world. In this respect, risk management has emerged as an important source of creativity and vision that is enhancing the competitive edge and, in some cases, the survival rate of many contrac­tors. Managing risk has been transformed from a once-a-year insurance bidding frenzy to a serious management initiative that has the ability to boost returns, create equity, reduce costs and permanently change the way con­struction firms are managed.

The risk management technology available today has long passed the traditional construction risk insurance policy buyer in favor of sophisticated construction firms that are astute enough to put each and every risk dollar to work for the compa­ny, stabilizing and reducing cost while leveling out the losses. The following represents a few selected risk management technologies that contractors are embracing to weather the storm.

Contract Documents

Allocating risk on construction projects continues to be an often-over­looked area in analyzing risk profiles for contractors. The effective use of hold harmless and indemnification agreements can reduce, and oftentimes manage, specific types of losses (par­ticularly "action-over" lawsuits) that would have been otherwise absorbed into the contractor's operations or insurance program. To capitalize on this technology:

  1. A standard subcontract document and purchase order should be re­viewed for enforceability within the state venues of work and updated periodically to incorporate state laws. Whatever form is chosen, this agreement should serve as the basis for distributing risk within projects.
  2. This standard subcontract/purchase order should contain specific lan­guage with respect to types of poli­cies/coverages required, minimum limits of liability and endorsements that protect the interest of the con­struction entity seeking indemnity. For example:
  • Additional Insured -adding the name of the general contractor to a subcontractor's general liability policy as an additional insured. Due to the new proprietary forms being used by insurers, this is becoming a challenging issue with regard to completed operations, ongoing operations, residential restrictions and indemnity agreements. There are countless forms being used, with many having significant restrictions on additional insured benefits/status. To date, we have identified fifteen serious restrictions or exclusions contained in many of the forms with the intent to restrict or even withdraw additional insured benefits to the contractor.
  • Insurance Considered Primary -the liability program of the subcontractor or sub­-subcontractor shall be considered primary in the event of a loss.
  • Cancellation Notice -usually as much as sixty days for cancella­tion and/or non-renewal is desired.
  • Waiver of Subrogation -to avoid subrogation proceedings on losses by the subcontractor's insurer.

  • As a rule, coverages should include general liability, automobile liability, worker's compensation, umbrella and certain types of property poli­cies, such as builder's risk/installa­tion floater for work to be installed or erected. Coverage areas need to be quite specific and include limits, endorsement language and specific reference to the indemnification agreement signed by the parties. Additional coverages, such as professional liability or pollution liability, should be carefully examined, depending upon the project scope.
  • Each project file should contain a standard certificate of insurance specifying coverages and limits and should include actual additional insured endorsements. All coverages, particularly liability, should be maintained throughout the project and continued for a given period of time (typically two to five years) after completion.
  • An audit of the certificate process should be conducted annually on major projects and on subcontractors to verify that the administration of the contract area is being monitored properly.
  • A contract checklist should be drafted for review between the contractor and the owner of the project noting specific areas such as limits required and special coverages (e.g., Owner's/Contractor's Protec­tive, Railroad Protective). This checklist can be given to the project bid team for cost analysis, and should include specific owner project financing information
  • max
    mid
    min

    © Copyright Construction Business Owners 2012. All Rights Reserved. Privacy Policy | Terms & Conditions