Home » Blogs

Blogs

Revenue Analysis – Dollars, Not Quarters!

 

First of all I apologize that it has been a long time since the last post.  The holiday season this year has been more challenging than most. 

 

The winter months have always been difficult for most contracting businesses because of weather-related work delays.  During these months contractors basically live off their savings that they built up during the peak summer months. 

 

November and December add additional challenges because with the holidays we typically can only work about 70% of the time on “revenue generating” field activities while maintaining most of our overhead costs. 

 

With the economy having depleted most of the profits that contractors made during the summer and also making 2009 backlogs weak the months of November and December have been especially trying. 

 

We have been working with our clients relentlessly during the last couple months helping them get through these months.  The basics are simple – the execution is very, very hard:

 

  1. Shed ALL costs that don’t generate profits and cash
  2. Be relentless about selection of revenue

 

Regarding item #1 when we say ‘ALL’ we mean ‘ALL’.  Literally you should run a report from your accounting system listing out every expense for the last three months and go through it line-by-line.  Every expense should be looked at and ranked in descending order about how it is linked to profitability and cash generation. 

 

Don’t try to make too many stretches here – if there doesn’t seem to be a direct link between an expense and profitability or cash then there probably isn’t!  For some more ideas on cutting costs there is an article by our LeAnn Evoniuk, our Financial Solutions manager: 

 

Cut the Fat, Thriving During an Economic Downturn

(http://www.dbrownmanagement.com/docs/article_cut_the_fat.pdf)

 

Regarding item #2 – this is just as critical.  Cutting costs is a huge first step but you usually can’t cost-cut your way to profitability.  The other side of the equation is that you need to bring in high-quality revenue. 

 

This sounds like common sense but typically when we end up doing a revenue analysis with a company we find a lot of inefficiency in the use of resources.  Here’s where to start:

 

  1. Going back 24 months make a list that contains all projects with revenue, direct job costs, margin and completion date
  2. Add in fields for customer and type of work (service, commercial, healthcare, industrial, etc.)
  3. Summarize the list by customer listing the quantity of projects, last completion date, totals for revenue and profit and then add two columns showing the percentage of total revenue and percentage of total margin – Microsoft Excel has a feature called ‘Pivot Table’ that is perfect for this analysis
  4. Sort the list in descending order by percentage of percentage of total margin
  5. Sort another list in descending order by percentage of total revenue
  6. Sort one more list in descending order by the last completion date

 

Now is time to sit down with your top team and start asking some hard questions.  Don’t stop with the surface level answers – dig down peeling back the layers of the onion on every one of these:

  1. Review the list sorted by margin and look at the sources near the top.  Hopefully none of your customers make up more than 15% of your margin – if they do you may have too much concentration with one customer leaving you exposed if they run into problems.  If this is the case you should be looking hard at how to diversify a little more. 
  2. Start adding up the percentages of total margin on the list and find those that create 80% of your total margin.  Most likely this list is relatively short compared to the total customers served.  Start brainstorming the ways to develop new customers that fit the profile of these “Top Producers”
  3. Review the list sorted by “Last Date” and see if there are any opportunities there to recapture revenue from past customers.  If there are customers on this list that fall within your “Top Producer” category that you haven’t done work for in a while it is probably worth starting there from a business development perspective.
  4. Look at the bottom of the list sorted by margin and start at the bottom having a very thorough discussion about each starting at the bottom and working your way up – the key question:  “What value does this customer truly add to our business?”  Like the expenses now is not the time to mince words – be relentless.  If you can’t clearly articulate the value the customer adds to your company then start looking for ways to shed these “Bad Customers” in a way that won’t hurt your reputation.

 

How many of your expenses have gone into supporting “Bad Customers?”  You may want to go back to your review of expenses and take another look.

 

This exercise should give you a much clearer idea about where your money and profits are truly coming from.  There are additional elements that we will discuss more in the future but this will get you started improving both the quality and quantity of your revenue.

 

The basics – you need to be relentless in your focus on high-quality revenue. 

 

My six year old daughter is just learning about money and already has the basics mastered.  For the last few years she has really liked the spare change – it is shiny, heavy and fun to play with.  Now that she is getting old enough to want important things like dolls and such from the store she has realized that pennies, nickels, dimes and even quarters don’t go that far!  Starting appropriately on January 1, 2009 she woke up and simply stated

 

“I don’t want to get paid in quarters – I need DOLLARS!“ 

 

I can’t think of any simpler of a way to describe the revenue strategies that we need to focus on to work our way through the current economy. 

 

Closing on a positive note EVERY one of our clients who has been relentless about business development during the last few months has actually increased revenue even during the downturn.  I cannot reiterate how critical aggressive business development is during these times.

Tags: , ,

3 Responses to “Revenue Analysis – Dollars, Not Quarters!”

  1. mmoore Says:

    Excellent thought provoking post, David. Are you actually seeing your clients increase gross revenue or are they able to generate more profit by focusing on better jobs/clients and a more efficient operation? I am curious to know because one of my stump speeches is that it isn’t necessary to be the “biggest” contractor in town in terms of gross revenue – but rather to be the most profitable by focusing on business fundamentals. Sometimes less gross revenue can yield a better lifestyle for the company owner (less stress/more manageable staff size) if he increases profit margin. I have found some folks – myself included – tend to hang on to overhead for too long from the fear of not being able to produce the “big job” that is lurking around the corner. I would submit now is not the time to hoard overhead but instead to cling to cash as much as possible. Your ideas to cut to the quick through analysis are spot on.

    Thanks. I have so often found my 4 and 2 year old speak more innocent wisdom than I am ever able to!

  2. David Brown Says:

    Michael – thank you for the compliments. I completely agree with you that it is “Quality” rather than “Quantity” of revenue that matters the most. Our business is about helping contractors grow so we are always looking for both.

    Usually for the contractor focused on growth they will tend to stretch a little too much. Too much diversification, too much leverage, too much overhead, etc. This is natural and perfectly OK in a rapidly expanding economy as long as it is realized and there is a plan to bring everything back in check.

    What we are very focused on right now is helping some of them bring their companies back in check which means usually means cutting bad revenue and trying to replace it with quality revenue. It also means cutting back on unnecessary overhead expenses but we try to avoid cutting into the bone unless the contractor really can’t generate additional revenue.

    Unfortunately we see too many businesses who are cutting too far without looking for ways to increase revenue. Taking your company to “fighting weight” is a good strategy – cutting beyond that may let you survive a little longer but it won’t make you strong enough to keep hunting for food.

    With your clients if you were to divide them into categories of Thriving, Surviving and Pending Failure what would you say the key differences are between those categories in the way the companies are managed?

  3. mmoore Says:

    Not being in the same business such that you are, I am certain there are many more you could mention – these are a few that I notice.

    Thriving – have a sound business plan that the entire company understands and promotes; understand their core business and aggressively market to that core type of client (and then follow up with excellent customer service and quality product); manage overhead well; very little debt.

    Surviving – Have a concept business plan; tend to wait for the phone to ring instead of developing a marketing plan; low to no backlog; generate enough cash to remain complacent; relatively low debt loads; often are excellent service providers that have found a niche, but have reached a plateau.

    Pending Failure – Very little to no Action Plan; Low employee buy-in and morale; react to issues and are not proactive; do not forecast; do not estimate costs well; no marketing plan; lack focus.

Leave a Reply

Copyright © 2010 Cahaba Media Group. All rights reserved.Magazine Publishing Consultants | Print, Web, and Digital Magazine Solutions | Advontemedia Inc.

 An  inc 5000 logo for email comp.jpg Company